Which States Pay More in Federal Taxes Than They Receive?
Uncover the federal fiscal balance of US states. See which contribute more in taxes than they receive and why.
The financial relationship between states and the federal government is of interest. It involves comparing tax revenue flowing from a state’s residents and businesses to the U.S. Treasury, with federal spending returning through programs, grants, and contracts. This analysis provides insight into the nation’s fiscal connections.
Understanding Net Fiscal Balance
A state’s net fiscal balance quantifies its financial interaction with the federal government. It represents the difference between federal taxes paid by individuals and businesses and federal funds received. A positive net fiscal balance indicates a state contributes more in federal taxes than it receives, while a negative balance signifies the opposite.
Calculating this balance involves assessing revenue and expenditure. Federal taxes include individual income, corporate income, payroll taxes for Social Security and Medicare, and excise taxes. Revenues are attributed to the state of tax liability origin. Individual income tax is attributed to the taxpayer’s state of residence, while corporate taxes are allocated based on economic activity.
Federal funds flow back through several channels. These include direct payments to individuals (e.g., Social Security, Medicare, veterans’ benefits) and federal grants to state and local governments for programs like Medicaid, education, transportation, and income security. Federal spending also covers salaries for federal employees and contracts awarded to businesses.
Measuring these figures presents complexities. Attributing corporate tax revenue is challenging due to multinational operations across many states. Tracking the ultimate beneficiaries of “pass-through” grants, from states to local governments, is intricate. Analyses provide a view of these fiscal flows, though precise attribution is difficult.
States That Contribute More Than They Receive
Based on recent data, a consistent group of states, often called “donor states,” contributes more in federal taxes than they receive. In 2023, approximately 19 states were in this category. The largest net contribution gaps were in New York, California, and New Jersey. Other top net contributors include Minnesota, Delaware, Illinois, and Florida.
On a per-person basis, Delaware, Minnesota, and New Jersey had high net contributions in 2023. Delaware led all states in federal taxes paid per resident, partly due to business incorporation. Minnesota paid significantly more in taxes than it received back in one analysis.
Economic and demographic characteristics explain these donor states’ net contributor status. Many have robust economies, higher average household incomes, and strong financial or technology industries, leading to greater individual income tax collections and substantial federal tax revenue. Top earners in California and New York contribute significant national income tax revenue.
These states have a lower reliance on certain federal programs or installations compared to recipient states. They may have fewer federal employees, military bases, or a smaller proportion of their population receiving federal benefits like Social Security or Medicare. This combination of high tax generation and lower federal expenditure results in their status as net fiscal contributors.
Key Determinants of a State’s Federal Fiscal Balance
Several factors determine whether a state becomes a net contributor or recipient of federal funds. Economic factors are key, as a state’s economic output and per capita income influence federal taxes collected. Higher GDP and average individual incomes generate more revenue from individual income taxes and corporate profits. The types of industries present also impact tax generation; financial, technology, or manufacturing sectors see higher tax receipts.
Demographic factors also influence the federal fiscal balance. The age distribution of a state’s population affects federal benefits received. More elderly residents receive more in Social Security and Medicare payments, as these are entitlement programs. Conversely, states with a younger, working-age population might contribute more in payroll taxes relative to immediate benefits received.
Poverty rates and health status within a state are important. States with higher poverty rates or greater health needs receive more federal assistance through programs like Medicaid, jointly funded by federal and state governments. Their funding allocations reflect the socio-economic characteristics and health demands of a state’s population.
Federal spending patterns shape a state’s fiscal balance. Large federal installations, like military bases or national laboratories, bring federal payroll and operational spending. Federal contracts awarded to businesses also represent an inflow of funds. States with defense contractors or research institutions receive federal investment. A state’s reliance on federal grants for programs like infrastructure or education boosts federal funds, impacting its net fiscal balance.