When Retirees Should Not Pay Off Their Mortgages

It is a widely held belief that entering retirement with a fully paid-off mortgage is the ultimate financial goal. This perspective often stems from a desire for peace of mind and the elimination of a significant monthly expense. However, this common assumption does not universally apply to every retiree’s financial situation. The decision to pay off a mortgage before or during retirement involves a complex evaluation of individual financial circumstances, including cash flow, investment opportunities, tax implications, and future needs. This article will explore various scenarios where retaining a mortgage might be a more financially advantageous approach for retirees.

Allocating Funds to Other Critical Needs

Prioritizing immediate and predictable financial needs often takes precedence over eliminating a mortgage balance. A robust emergency fund, typically 12 to 24 months of living expenses for retirees, provides a financial cushion for unforeseen events like medical emergencies, home repairs, or unexpected travel, which is particularly important given potential increased healthcare costs and reduced income flexibility.

Addressing high-interest consumer debt, such as credit card balances, generally offers a more immediate and tangible financial benefit than paying down a lower-interest mortgage. Credit card annual percentage rates (APRs) can often range from 18% to over 25%, with the average hovering around 20% to 25%, making the interest expense significantly higher than typical mortgage rates. Eliminating these high-cost obligations first helps to free up cash flow and reduce financial strain more effectively.

Funding healthcare costs and other essential living expenses is a significant priority. Retirees face rising healthcare expenditures, including insurance premiums, deductibles, co-pays, and prescription medications. A 65-year-old couple can expect to spend an average of $315,000 on healthcare expenses throughout retirement, not including long-term care. Allocating capital to cover these predictable costs ensures stability and access to necessary care.

Maintaining sufficient liquidity for daily living expenses, rather than tying up capital in a home, allows for greater financial flexibility in retirement. For instance, the average 65-year-old couple may spend around $12,800 on healthcare in their first year of retirement, illustrating the need for accessible funds. Having cash reserves available helps manage these ongoing expenses without needing to sell assets or incur new debt.

Investing for Growth and Inflation Protection

The concept of opportunity cost is significant when deciding whether to pay off a mortgage or invest funds. Money used to extinguish a mortgage could instead be strategically invested, potentially generating returns surpassing the interest rate saved. A diversified investment portfolio, including equities and fixed-income assets, could target an average annual return of 5% to 7% long-term, often exceeding existing mortgage rates.

Various investment vehicles are suitable for retirees seeking growth and income. Dividend-paying stocks can provide a steady stream of income, while income-generating bonds offer relative stability and regular interest payments. Investing in real estate beyond one’s primary residence, such as rental properties, can also generate income and potential appreciation. These investment avenues provide opportunities for capital growth that can help offset the effects of inflation.

Inflation gradually erodes the purchasing power of money over time, making fixed-rate debt like a mortgage less burdensome in real terms as years pass. With historical inflation averaging around 3% annually, the real value of a fixed mortgage payment diminishes over a 15-year or 30-year term. This inflation-induced erosion of debt, combined with the potential for investment growth, suggests that invested capital can outpace the effective cost of a mortgage, thereby protecting a retiree’s overall financial strength against rising prices.

Optimizing Retirement Income and Tax Strategy

Retaining a mortgage can contribute to a more stable and tax-efficient retirement by preserving liquid cash flow. Rather than having a large portion of one’s wealth illiquidly tied up in a home, maintaining a mortgage allows assets to remain accessible for unexpected expenses or investment opportunities. This liquidity can be crucial for managing cash flow in retirement, where income streams might be less predictable than during working years.

Mortgage interest can offer a valuable tax deduction for some retirees, potentially reducing their overall taxable income. Homeowners who itemize deductions on their federal tax returns may deduct interest paid on up to $750,000 of qualified mortgage debt. While many taxpayers now utilize the standard deduction, which for 2025 is projected to be around $15,300 for single filers and $30,700 for those married filing jointly, itemizing can still be beneficial if combined deductions, including mortgage interest, exceed these amounts. This deduction effectively lowers the net cost of carrying the mortgage.

Property taxes represent an ongoing expense for homeowners, regardless of whether their mortgage is paid off. These taxes are levied by local governments and typically increase over time, remaining a continuous financial obligation. While property taxes can also be itemized deductions, they are subject to a limitation of $10,000 annually when combined with state and local income or sales taxes. Therefore, eliminating the mortgage payment does not eliminate the entire cost of homeownership, as property taxes and insurance premiums persist.

Addressing Future Needs and Legacy Considerations

Retaining a mortgage provides financial flexibility, which is invaluable for addressing unforeseen future expenses. As individuals age, the likelihood of needing long-term care, such as in-home assistance, assisted living, or nursing home care, increases significantly. The costs associated with long-term care can be substantial, often ranging from $5,000 to over $10,000 per month depending on the level of care and geographic location. Having liquid assets rather than all wealth concentrated in a fully paid-off home offers a greater ability to cover these potentially immense costs without having to sell the primary residence.

Significant home repairs or necessary modifications for aging in place also represent potential future expenditures. While a home might be structurally sound, systems like HVAC, roofing, or plumbing eventually require replacement or extensive repair, which can cost tens of thousands of dollars. Funds not used to pay off a mortgage can serve as a readily available reserve for these types of large, infrequent expenses, preserving the comfort and safety of one’s home.

Keeping a mortgage can also form part of a thoughtful estate planning strategy. Instead of leaving heirs with only a fully paid-off home that might require liquidation to cover estate expenses or provide for multiple beneficiaries, retaining a mortgage allows retirees to preserve more liquid assets or a diversified investment portfolio. This approach can provide heirs with greater financial flexibility, enabling them to inherit a mix of assets that aligns better with their own financial needs and goals, rather than inheriting an illiquid asset that they might not wish to maintain.

Citations

• Average Credit Card Interest Rate in US Today | LendingTree.
• Topic No. 504 Home Mortgage Interest Deduction – IRS.gov.
• United States Inflation Rate – 2025 Data – 1914-2024 Historical – 2026 Forecast – TRADING ECONOMICS.
• IRS announces 2025 tax brackets, standard deduction amounts.
• What Is the Standard Deduction for 2025? – Investopedia.
• How Big Should Your Emergency Fund Be When You’re Retired? – AARP.
• Here’s How Much Retirees Should Keep in an Emergency Fund – Nasdaq.
• Emergency fund planning: How much cash should I have on hand? | T. Rowe Price.
• Retired? Here’s How Much You Actually Need in Your Emergency Fund | The Motley Fool.
• 6 Emergency Fund Mistakes to Avoid After 50 – AARP.
• Health Care Costs in Retirement: Plan to Protect Your Future.
• How much will health care cost you in retirement? – Communications – Fidelity Investments.
• How Much Should You Budget for Healthcare in Retirement? – Creative Planning.