Accounting Concepts and Practices

Accounting for Early Termination of Contract

When a contract ends early, specific accounting is required. Learn to correctly derecognize associated balance sheet items and report the resulting financial impact.

An early contract termination occurs when an agreement is ended before its specified completion date. This action requires careful accounting, as the financial outcome can be a gain or a loss for the parties involved. Properly accounting for this event is necessary for maintaining accurate financial statements that reflect the company’s current obligations and economic reality.

The accounting treatment must capture the complete financial impact, including any termination fees and the removal of related assets and liabilities from the balance sheet. The goal is to present a clear picture of the termination’s effect on the company’s financial position in the period it occurs.

Initial Assessment and Information Gathering

Before any financial entries are recorded, a business must gather all relevant documentation. The process begins with a detailed review of the original contract and any subsequent amendments. These documents outline the initial terms and obligations that are being extinguished and provide the baseline for calculating the financial impact.

A central document in this process is the formal termination agreement. This legal document specifies the official date of termination, which dictates the timing of the accounting recognition. It also details the financial considerations, such as any penalty fees to be paid or received.

The next step involves a precise calculation of the carrying amounts of any assets or liabilities on the balance sheet directly associated with the contract. For a lease termination, this would include the right-of-use asset and the lease liability. For a customer contract, it might involve a contract liability, known as deferred revenue, for payments received for services yet to be rendered. The company must also identify any other direct costs associated with the termination, such as legal fees.

Accounting Treatment for the Payer

For the party ending the contract and making a payment, the accounting treatment centers on recognizing the cost and removing all related items from the balance sheet. Any termination fee is recognized as an expense or a loss in the period the contract is officially terminated. The company must also derecognize, or remove, any assets and liabilities that were established as part of the original contract. The difference between the carrying amounts of these items and the cash paid constitutes the total gain or loss.

A common example is the early termination of an operating lease, governed by ASC 842. When a lessee terminates a lease, it must remove both the right-of-use (ROU) asset and the lease liability from its balance sheet. Any payment made to the lessor as a termination penalty is factored into the calculation of the overall gain or loss.

For example, assume a company terminates a lease and pays a $50,000 penalty. At the termination date, its lease liability has a carrying value of $400,000, and its ROU asset has a carrying value of $380,000. The journal entry would include a debit to the lease liability for $400,000, a credit to the ROU asset for $380,000, and a credit to cash for the $50,000 penalty. The remaining $30,000 difference would be debited as a loss on lease termination, which is recognized immediately on the income statement.

Accounting Treatment for the Recipient

For the party receiving a termination payment, the accounting treatment focuses on recognizing the income and clearing any related obligations. The termination fee is recognized as revenue or other income in the period the contract is terminated. Upon termination, the recipient must also derecognize any liabilities associated with the contract, such as deferred revenue for services that will no longer be provided.

Consider a scenario guided by ASC 606. A software-as-a-service (SaaS) company has a multi-year contract with a customer who decides to terminate early and pays a $100,000 termination fee. At the time of termination, the SaaS company has a $20,000 contract liability on its balance sheet for subscription fees paid in advance by the customer.

The journal entry for the recipient would involve a debit to cash for the $100,000 received and a debit to the contract liability for $20,000 to remove it from the balance sheet. The corresponding credit would be to a termination revenue or gain account for the total amount of $120,000. This entry reflects both the cash received and the reversal of the liability that is no longer an obligation.

Financial Statement Presentation and Disclosures

After the accounting entries are recorded, the financial impact must be properly presented in the financial statements and detailed in the accompanying footnotes. On the income statement, the resulting gain or loss is reported within income from continuing operations. If the amount is material, it is often presented as a separate line item to provide transparency to financial statement users.

On the balance sheet, the primary effect is the removal of the assets and liabilities associated with the terminated contract. For example, a lessee would no longer report a right-of-use asset or a lease liability. This presentation reflects that the company no longer has rights to or obligations from the canceled agreement.

Footnote disclosures provide context for the financial impact of the termination. Guided by standards such as ASC 420, companies should provide a description of the termination event and its circumstances. The disclosures must also detail the main terms of the termination agreement, state the total amount of the gain or loss recognized, and specify the line item on the income statement where it is recorded. For costs associated with the termination, a reconciliation of the related liability from the beginning to the end of the period should be provided.

Previous

ASC 840: Lease Classification and Accounting Rules

Back to Accounting Concepts and Practices
Next

ASC 310-20: Accounting for Loan Fees and Costs